第三十屆香港電影金像獎 + 電影短評

打擂台 - 睇好 1 + 超希望獲獎

劍雨 - 睇好 2 + 超希望獲獎

綫人 - 睇好 3 + 希望獲獎


葉問 2

滄海遺珠: 東風破

討論: 《志明與春嬌》值得提名最佳電影?
Kenji's Review: http://hk.myblog.yahoo.com/kenji-chan/article?mid=11068


郭子健、鄭思傑《打擂台》- 睇好 1

蘇照彬《劍雨》- 睇好 2

林超賢《綫人》- 睇好 3




郭子健、鄭思傑、譚廣源《打擂台》- 睇好







張家輝《綫人》- 睇好 1

謝霆鋒《綫人》- 睇好 2


周潤發《孔子 決戰春秋》- 未睇

梁家輝《李小龍》- 未睇

滄海遺珠: 甄子丹《葉問2

最佳女主角 - 好難揀得落手



楊千嬅《志明與春嬌》- 睇好 + 唔希望獲獎


何超儀《維多利亞壹號》- 未睇

滄海遺珠: 官恩娜《東風破》、吳君如《得閒炒飯》


泰迪羅賓《打擂台》- 睇好 1

王學圻《劍雨》- 睇好 2

廖啟智《綫人》- 睇好 3



滄海遺珠: 劉永《復仇者之死》、洪金寶《葉問2


朱咪咪《月滿軒尼詩》- 睇好 1 + 希望獲獎

鮑起靜《月滿軒尼詩》 睇好 2 + 希望獲獎


張靜初《全城戒備》- 未睇

余安安《飛砂風中轉》- 未睇

滄海遺珠: 苗可秀《東風破》


彭冠期《安非他命》- 希望獲獎

杜宇航《葉問前傳》- 睇好



陳奐仁《李小龍》- 未睇


關智耀《東風破》- 睇好 1 + 希望獲獎

黃永恒《劍雨》- 睇好 2 + 希望獲獎



鮑德熹《孔子 決戰春秋》- 未睇

最佳剪接 - No Comment





鄺志良《鎗王之王》- 未睇


楊百貴、蘇國豪《劍雨》- 睇好

趙崇邦《狄仁傑之通天帝國》- 睇好


林潮翔、毛懷清《孔子 決戰春秋》- 未睇

張世宏《李小龍》- 未睇

滄海遺珠: 東風破


余家安《狄仁傑之通天帝國》- 睇好 1

和田惠美《劍雨》- 睇好 2

奚仲文《孔子 決戰春秋》- 未睇

張世傑《李小龍》- 未睇

吳里璐《精武風雲.陳真》- 未睇


洪金寶《葉問 2- 睇好 1

董瑋《劍雨》- 睇好 2

洪金寶《狄仁傑之通天帝國》- 睇好 3


甄子丹《精武風雲.陳真》- 未睇


Hero To Stay《東風破》- 希望獲獎

Have A Good Life《戀人絮語》- 希望獲獎



幽蘭操《孔子 決戰春秋》- 未睇

滄海遺珠: 呼吸需要《志明與春嬌》


岸西《月滿軒尼詩》- 希望獲獎 + 睇好

莊文強《飛砂風中轉》- 未睇

黃國兆《酒徒》- 未睇

最佳亞洲電影 - I like all of them indeed

告白 - 希望獲獎




父後七日- 未睇


殺神少女:漢娜 Hanna 3 / 5

Directed by Joe Wright (Atonement), Hanna is a road movie about a special girl's growth. Please bear in mind that it is not an action movie. Some images are visually stunning and some scenes are of good tension. Cate Blanchett's performance is good. Her performance in the scene showing her character telling the old lady she has not given birth to a baby stays in my mind for long, but generally she lacks opportunities to showcase her acting talent. Saoirse Ronan's performance is also convincing. However, the characters need to be further developed and the relationships are not clear enough. The bad guys are not threatening enough and the relation between "fairy tale" and her pursuit of revenge is not clear. A disappointment! P.S. I have not seen 奇鸚嘉年華 and 依法犯法, but they are also well received. If you have time, perhaps you may go watch them.

一年未緣 Another Year 4.5 / 5

Another year is one of the best films I have seen this year. The ensemble acting is superb and the characters are three dimensional. I especially feel sorry for the lady whose life is painful. As we grow older, there seems to be more and more problems. How can we stay happy? The film does not provide us with an answer. It just shows the problems and the ending looks pessimistic. Perhaps that is the nature of our lives.

愛有新世界 In a Better World / Hævnen 4.3 / 5

In a Better World has big themes and forces me to think about the decisions I make every day in moral dilemmas. Wether or not we should fight back depends on different situations. If possible, I try to avoid conflicts of course. The characters take revenge on one another and fortunately the movie is a better world. Anyway, I like it, but I still prefer the quirky Dogtooth from Greece and Confession from Japan.

愛情潛水 Submarine 4.1 / 5

A quirky and humorous coming-of-age story with a refreshing cast, visually stunning images and catchy music. It reminds me of 500 Days of Summer!!! However, the changes in his parents' relationship can be further developed. I love it!!!

母親的告白 Incendies 3.9 / 5

A gripping story with impressive cinematography and a capable cast, but I am not convinced by the strange coincidence.

我,看見惡魔 I Saw the Devil 3.5 / 5
I Saw the Devil has gory images and the atmosphere is frightening. However, the characters are not well developed and there are plotholes here and there. I think it is worth watching, but don't expect too much. I highly recommend to you another Korean movie, "Memories of Murder".

28 則留言:

  1. 完全沒心水, 只係支持"打擂台" . :-)
    [版主回覆04/09/2011 13:05:00]A sincerely made movie. Have you seen 劍雨? It is gripping and beautifully shot!

  2. 可唔可以講下點解唔希望楊千嬅獲獎 ??
    [版主回覆04/10/2011 00:57:00]I have stated the reason in my review: "although Miriam Yeung is able to perform naturally, her
    character is not three dimensional enough to showcase her acting skills.
    Judging from her character’s tone and choice of words, the audience only sees
    Miriam, instead of Cherie in the movie. Miriam's character should be called Miriam.
    Moreover, the scene in which she argues with her husband in the bedroom is
    devoid of tension, which is a solid proof of her average performance." Try to compare the scene with the kitchen scene in Blue Valentine starring Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams. You may notice the huge difference. Having
    said that, I am her FAN frankly speaking haha. I LOVE her songs and
    personality. Her singing skills and acting skills can be further
    improved though.

  3. 我好喜歡看《打擂台》希望得獎 。美術指導及攝影我希望《劍雨》得獎...好緊張
    [版主回覆04/10/2011 00:45:00]YES both are good films. Indeed I am glad that there were some good Hong Kong movies last year.

  4. 我要看多幾部香港製造才可以了,大多也是聽其名,未看過呢!
    [版主回覆04/10/2011 00:49:00]Last year, there were some good Hong Kong movies. I highly recommend: 打擂台 劍雨 綫人 歲月神偷 東風破 月滿軒尼詩 安非他命

  5. Rio好好睇,歌好聽,故事也動人。
    [版主回覆04/10/2011 23:10:00]Some people say that Rio has great images and music, but the story lacks surprises. Do you think so? Are there any messages? Thanks a lot.

  6. "月滿軒尼詩"我睇到一半就爛尾無睇哂啦....
    我睇"酒徒"個故事簡介, 十分似"2046"...好似十足抄咁....
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 11:24:00]酒徒's trailer is off-putting. 月滿軒尼詩 surprises me indeed. I like the characters and the setting.

  7. 好少睇香港戲,睇過嘅電影,覺得周潤發同Teddy Robin,邵音音都演得好好,至於楊千嬅...同你想法好相似.
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 21:39:00]I admit that Miriam is able to perform naturally, but that she is able to do so does not mean that she deserves the award. I agree with another blogger 阿牛 that 今年的女主角候選名單是出奇的弱,任誰勝出相信也不會是眾望所歸。 Only three at HKIFF because I have been very busy these days. How about you?

  8. 既然最佳電影冇【東風破】 ,咁就支持【打擂台】啦 我都想睇【父後七日】,聽講好過【當愛來的時候】好多。
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 22:03:00]I love both 打擂台 and 劍雨, but if I were asked to choose one, I would pick 打擂台 because of its passion for life. 父後七日's reviews are divided. I am worried that it is very boring. -_-

  9. My two cents: Agree that  打擂台 is a very refreshing movie and should really deserve a win .. but fear that it's probably not going to get sufficient votes to get the win.  Heart says  打擂台 but mind is leaning towards  綫人. Totally agree that Miriam should not win.  I thought  劉嘉玲 was very good and deserves a win but gather that  薛凱琪 was fantastic. And you should really check out  飛砂風中轉 .. it's hilarious!
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 22:44:00]I am just a bit worried that 打擂台 looks independent. Obviosuly it is less commercial than 綫人. 劉嘉玲's performance is quite good, but her character does not surprise me and she does not have much to act. 薛凱琪's performance is refreshing and pleasing indeed. Anyway, I prefer their performances to Miriam's. Thanks for your recommendation. I will watch it for sure in my spare time. 

  10. 音樂很有動感,我一邊看一邊好想一起跳舞 。而 images 好豐富。故事雖然沒什麼大驚喜,但是我覺得片中blue最後因愛而克服自己的弱點,亦治療好童年陰影,實在不錯﹗也提醒我生活要有勇氣^^面對自己的弱點。另外,《父後七日》不悶都有另一番意思。
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 22:46:00]They sound good. It is a pity that I have been busy these days.

  11. Little Wing - Wendy2011年4月11日 下午10:45

    你這個list,我原來只看過兩套香港電影 ~ 《志明與春嬌》和《月滿軒尼詩》
    而 最佳亞洲電影,我卻看了三套且覺得好看呢!!!!

    [版主回覆04/11/2011 23:03:00]I personally think 山楂樹之戀, 艋舺 and 唐山大地震 are also good movies. 告白 is my favourite one. I will also be happy if 山楂樹之戀 wins.

  12. np - from one movie buff to another. Did you check out many movies at this year's film festival?
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 23:04:00]what is np? Only 3 since I have been very busy these days!

  13. 睇得唔算多,幾套.好喜歡蛋奶蜜三部曲之蜂蜜.
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 23:11:00]1. I have heard of the movie. After watching the trailer, I guess it is visually stunning, but I am worried that the movie drags. 2. I think the chance is slim, considering its topic.

  14. "np" is short hand for "no problem". Well you do 2 better than me.  I only managed to catch Tofu Kozo ...
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 23:12:00]OIC HAHAHA!!! I am so OUT~~~~~~~~~~~~~

  15. nah - it's not meant to be "in" or any kind of "internet language" .. it's only one of those short hands we use when we are lazy ... 
    [版主回覆04/11/2011 23:19:00]Anyway, it is nice to talk about movies with you. Time to sleep. Thanks a lot!

  16. pleasure - check out my reviews on my blog when you have a mo!
    [版主回覆04/12/2011 11:58:00]mo stands for moment, yeah. Thanks for your invitation. See you!

  17. 我又覺得楊千嬅做志明與春嬌可拎最佳女主角,雖然好多人話做番自己,但我唔認同,之前接觸過佢,同春嬌其實性格有d唔同,另外好多人話佢套套戲都係做番自己,連餃子都係,或者係大家對佢既偏見la,而shawn yue o係志明與春嬌係做番自己本人咁濟,但又好多人覺得佢應該入五強,未免有d唔公平
    男配角應該有mc jin歐陽靖@李小龍/打擂台,兩套都做得好好,女配角:方皓玟帶到觀眾投入佢既角色,深情少少,同埋bitchy都交足戲
    [版主回覆04/12/2011 12:34:00]之前接觸過佢,同春嬌其實性格有d唔同 - Could you please tell us the subtle difference and how her acting differentiates the two characters, Miriam and Cherie? 另外好多人話佢做番自己或者係大家對佢既偏見 - I am her fan, but I have to say that I only see Miriam in this movie. Besides, the bedroom scene in which she argues with her husband is simply devoid of any tension. As for Shawn, I have not heard of people saying that he deserves a nomination. I think his performance is also average. Besides, I hope Fiona will win. Thanks for your sharing.

  18. 【當愛來的時候】雖然得獎,但係都幾悶下。我諗【父後七日】最多同佢差唔多悶掛? 【打擂台】真的很不錯,希望能夠獲獎!
    [版主回覆04/12/2011 12:36:00]父後七日 - the trailer looks boring... I wish 打擂台 every success. ^^

  19. 看過"母親的告白", 也聽過有人跟你相同意見, 覺得結果太過"扭橋", 不過我還是很喜歡那份懸疑性, 逐層透過追尋母親的身世, 講述疑似黎巴嫰的暴力史! "殺人回憶"是十分好的電影, 但跟"我, 看見惡魔"很不同, 因為前者主要是講緝兇, 但後者在很早時候已經確認到兇手, 大部份篇幅是報復, 味道較近"原罪犯"! 還在想好不好去看"In a better world"!
    [版主回覆04/12/2011 12:44:00]Agree that both movies are quite different, but the characters are not as well developed as the ones in The Old Boy. In a Better World is worth seeing. After all, it is the winner of the Best Foreign Langauge Film at both Oscar and Golden Globe. I love the theme, images and the ensemble cast. Hatred and revenge should be uprooted.

  20. 唔緊要啦~~有時間才去看吧﹗
    [版主回覆04/14/2011 10:06:00]OKOK!!!

  21. 估唔到劍雨都幾多提名,我有睇,覺得拍得都幾好睇,i mean d 畫面,武打~
    原創音樂0個幾首都唔錯阿 ^^ 一首好音樂真係對電影好重要!
    [版主回覆04/14/2011 10:12:00]I love After You've Gone in 東風破. It is a pity that it is not original song.

  22. 最佳亞洲電影提名, 我睇左3套, < 告白>, < 艋舺>及< 唐山大地震>, 三部都幾好, 整體來說, 我最喜歡<告白>, 連結尾, 女主角一句:"我玩你乍", 都充滿懸疑. 
    而只有<最佳男主角>那五部電影, 我係睇哂既. 《綫人》張家輝個角色, 心理複雜, 但家輝又掌握的好好, 再奪獎, 係正常. 張學友其實唔差架, 因為佢仲可以演活那種小人物, 少男心態, 殊不簡單. 周潤發"恰到好處", 梁家輝"恰如其分", 如果我選擇, 我會選張學友, 因為佢係演得最唔用力的一位.    
    [版主回覆04/14/2011 20:07:00]How about 謝霆鋒? I agree that 張家輝 掌握的好好 and 張學友其實唔差架. His carefree and immature character is well developed and Jacky's performance is convincing.

  23. 謝霆鋒在《綫人》的演出, 是保持水準, 未算好突出.
    [版主回覆04/14/2011 22:56:00]Agree that 未算好突出. 張家輝 has several memorable scenes. Thanks for your sharing.

  24. 個人認為全年最佳電影 與導演,俱屬《劍雨》,基本上是贏了一條街。最佳編劇《月滿軒尼斯》,最佳攝影則是《東風破》。
    [版主回覆04/15/2011 18:00:00]Hey long time no see. Thank you so much for your visit. Please asvise me of your new blog if there is any. 劍雨 is surely my cup of tea. Technically speaking, it is better than 打擂台. However, the sincerity of 打擂台 touches me. 月滿軒尼斯's atmosphere is well created and 東風破 is beautifully shot.

  25. 滄海遺珠 : 東風破 <-- LIKE ^_^
    [版主回覆04/16/2011 11:15:00](Empty)

  26. Memories of Murder 好像不是講復仇的?關於復仇的南韓電影,【原罪犯】應是最出色的了。
    [版主回覆04/17/2011 11:39:00]Right! Memories of Murder is about looking for a murderer and both stories are different haha. I recommend it because the atmosphere is more gripping. Sorry for not having stated why I compare both in detail haha. You are right. It is more appropriate to compare I Saw the Devil with Old Boy.

  27. 1. Some results are quite surprising. 2. The show is a bit too long. 3. I do love the theme - gratitude, since some people nowadays do not say thank you or sorry. 4. Chow Yun Fat is humorous!

  28. Nice to meet your blog !
    Happy Easter !
    [版主回覆04/20/2011 09:19:00]Welcome!!!